The work of the Simón Bolívar Symphony Orchestra earns a highlight on the Grammys
The Simón Bolívar Symphony Orchestra performing in 2013.
JUAN BARRETO/AFP through Getty Photographs/AFP
cover caption
toggle caption
JUAN BARRETO/AFP through Getty Photographs/AFP
A Grammy nomination is nothing new for conductor Gustavo Dudamel.
The music director designate of the New York Philharmonic, who’s at the moment concluding his 17-year-tenure as music and inventive director of the Los Angeles Philharmonic, has received seven Grammys over the course of his profession. This yr alone, he is nominated in three separate classes. However for the primary time, a kind of nominations is with an orchestra born from the musical system that raised Dudamel and launched his profession: the Simón Bolívar Symphony Orchestra (SBSO).
The orchestra is the flagship ensemble of Venezuela’s world-renowned music training program, generally often known as El Sistema. For many years, El Sistema has promoted classical music as a automobile for social change and growth, offering free and rigorous coaching to greater than 1,000,000 youngsters throughout Venezuela, in accordance with their very own figures. It has impressed related fashions and dozens of member organizations in different international locations. In recent times, El Sistema has additionally sparked backlash for its shut relationship with the Venezuelan authorities, which faces an unprecedented and unpredictable path ahead following the latest ousting of autocratic president Nicolás Maduro by U.S. forces.
Final spring, SBSO and Dudamel celebrated El Sistema’s fiftieth anniversary with a European tour and a recording of Ravel’s Boléro, which earned a Grammy nomination for greatest orchestral efficiency. The popularity from the Recording Academy could coincide with a turbulent second for Venezuela, however Eduardo Méndez, who has served as government director of El Sistema since 2008, says his focus is all the time on the music.
“This nomination, it is greater than being a very good recording or a good looking recording,” Méndez tells NPR. “It is actually an indication of what Venezuela can do. That is the vital factor — that we will see in our future how stunning we may be and the way good Venezuelans may be. We will do marvelous issues.”
From a storage to a global powerhouse
El Sistema started in a parking storage in 1975 with lower than a dozen college students. Underneath the management of maestro José Antonio Abreu, a musician and economist, it grew right into a government-funded social program aiming to create a tradition of musical excellence all through Venezuela. El Sistema established a community of youth orchestras throughout each single state, with a specific deal with underprivileged areas.
Méndez remembers his mother taking him to the native núcleo, or educating middle, in his hometown of Merida in 1983, when he was solely 5 years outdated. “I began going and I by no means stopped,” he says. “I nonetheless go to the núcleo day-after-day.”
He performed violin within the native youth orchestra via his teen years and stayed deeply related to this system whilst he pursued a legislation diploma. After commencement, Abreu mentored Méndez on the right way to run El Sistema and take over as his successor. Méndez’s story, although distinctive for his business, is just like that of many SBSO musicians. Initially this system’s flagship youth orchestra, SBSO has since expanded into an expert grownup ensemble, made up fully of musicians educated by El Sistema.
SBSO violinist Pathrycia Mendonça says she was principally born into this system; she began going to a núcleo in Barquisimeto as a small baby, following the footsteps of her older sister. “It isn’t simply coming to rehearsal and sitting and enjoying and [leaving],” Mendonça tells NPR. “We actually are like a household. We develop up collectively. We have now plenty of time collectively. I feel that that’s the secret.”
Carlos Chirinos-Espin, professor of music innovation and social growth at New York College, says El Sistema’s sense of belonging is essential to the Simón Bolívar Symphony Orchestra’s sound. He remembers throwing a celebration for SBSO’s debut efficiency in London in 2007, and watching the musicians blasting reggaeton and dancing collectively afterwards.
“This Venezuelan orchestra, they hang around. They go to the bar. They eat collectively. They maybe stay in the identical space,” he says. “They’ve developed friendships due to the El Sistema mannequin of training. The pedagogy and strategy to constructing a group undoubtedly has an affect on the standard of the efficiency itself. The Simón Bolívar Orchestra is proof of that.”
That bond, Chirinos-Espin says, stays even because the members of the orchestra have modified over time. Dudamel, who serves as musical director of SBSO, grew from conductor prodigy of the youth orchestra into maybe essentially the most well-known Venezuelan musician on the earth, reaching bonafide rock star standing within the classical music scene. Chirinos-Espin notes that whereas the curly-haired conductor’s ascent has been essentially the most notable and well-documented, there are many different alumni who’ve reached prestigious positions because of El Sistema’s coaching, together with conductors Rafael Payare (Montreal Symphony Orchestra/San Diego Symphony), Diego Matheuz (Seiji Ozawa Music Academy Orchestra in Tokyo) and Domingo Hindoyan (Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra).
The Simón Bolívar Symphony Orchestra acting at Wembley stadium.
Sisi Burn
cover caption
toggle caption
Sisi Burn
Controversies and clashes with the federal government
But for all of the worldwide approval for each the orchestra’s performances and its instructional spine, El Sistema and SBSO have additionally confronted controversies, together with allegations of sexual abuse inside its ranks. Most just lately, a number of former college students spoke out on social media in 2021, detailing accounts of sexual harassment throughout their time in El Sistema; the unbiased outlet Caracas Chronicles then interviewed a number of alleged victims utilizing pseudonyms to guard their identities. As soon as the allegations got here to gentle, El Sistema issued a assertion on X expressing “absolute solidarity with the victims and their households” and promising to research complaints and improve prevention protocols.
El Sistema has lengthy been largely funded by the federal government, courting again to its earliest mission of arming youngsters with management and social abilities via community-oriented music applications. However as late President Hugo Chávez and his successor, Maduro, consolidated energy, El Sistema shifted from the jurisdiction of a number of social ministries to the president’s workplace. Though the orchestra identifies as apolitical, Abreu and Dudamel had been usually pictured alongside authorities leaders; Dudamel carried out with the orchestra at Chavez’s funeral in 2013. Some critics — together with Venezuelan pianist Gabriela Montero — have accused El Sistema of serving as a propaganda instrument, pushing a optimistic picture of Venezuela whilst the federal government confronted rising accusations of authoritarianism and human rights violations.
When requested about these criticisms, Méndez would solely say that his job is to place the scholars first and maintain the tutorial program alive.
“We have now a mission. The mission is to unfold classical music, to provide entry [to] classical music to each baby and each youth within the nation and maybe on the earth,” he says. “We won’t cease. When you cease, you lose the kids. Schooling cannot cease. [The children] should take two or three buses a day to get to a núcleo, however they go day-after-day. So in the event that they go, we have now to be there to show.”
Because the nation’s socioeconomic disaster deepened over the previous decade, forcing roughly 1 / 4 of its inhabitants to flee, a pointy dissonance got here into focus: on one facet, there was a social program promising to assist deprived youth out of poverty via the ability of music. On the opposite, a rustic with crumbling infrastructure that left those self same youngsters with few prospects for his or her future. That is maybe most clearly illustrated in Marianela Maldonado’s documentary Youngsters of Las Brisas, which adopted the lives of three El Sistema college students over almost a decade, and captured their rising desperation beneath the burden of Venezuela’s situations.
A type of musicians, Wuilly Arteaga, grew to become a distinguished face of anti-government protests in 2017, enjoying his violin in entrance of armed troopers (later he wrote of being jailed and tortured, and was finally compelled into exile). Round that very same time, the Venezuelan Nationwide Guard killed an 18-year-old El Sistema violist named Armando Cañizales at an anti-government demonstration. The subsequent day, Dudamel penned a assertion condemning the continuing violence, marking his first time publicly weighing in on Venezuela’s political repression.
“I urgently name on the President of the Republic and the nationwide authorities to rectify and hearken to the voice of the Venezuelan folks. Instances can’t be outlined by the blood of our folks,” he wrote. “We owe our youth a hopeful world, a rustic the place we will stroll freely in dissent, in respect, in tolerance, in dialogue and wherein goals have room to construct the Venezuela all of us yearn for.”
He adopted the letter with an op-ed within the New York Instances, calling Maduro’s plans to type a brand new legislative physique and take energy away from the opposition-led Nationwide Meeting “unconstitutional.” Quickly after, Maduro canceled the Nationwide Youth Orchestra’s deliberate U.S. tour. The way forward for El Sistema and its touring orchestras hung within the interim.
“Many people had doubts after 2017. I had doubts,” Chirinos-Espin says. “Is El Sistema going to proceed to be what it was? Is that legacy going to proceed? As a result of they did not tour and I wasn’t in a position to go to Venezuela; I wasn’t in a position to see.”
After Abreu’s demise in 2018, the Nationwide Youth Symphony Orchestra and musicians from SBSO participated in two tribute live shows in Chile for El Sistema’s founder. Following the COVID-19 pandemic, SBSO didn’t embark on one other main worldwide tour till its residency on the Edinburgh Worldwide Pageant in 2023, adopted by performances throughout Asia.
A triumphant return
Méndez acknowledges that working El Sistema with the political and social backdrop of latest years has been difficult.
“It would not matter what occurs outdoors, we’re all the time centered on what we’re doing,” he says. “What we have now performed is maintain the power centered on optimistic issues and on connecting classical music to the folks. That is why we have now been very motivated, all of us — the musicians, the workers, the administration, everybody — as a result of we actually consider that what we’re doing helps the event of the nation.”
In 2025, months after a widely-contested presidential election wherein Maduro declared himself the winner with out presenting proof of a victory, SBSO’s fiftieth anniversary tour started. The January dates throughout Europe overlapped with the beginning of Maduro’s new time period, resulting in allegations from pianist Gabriela Montero that SBSO was “music-washing” a stolen election. Although she inspired music promoters and artists to boycott the tour, the European performances continued as deliberate.
SBSO violinist Pathrycia Mendonça says that in each metropolis, Venezuelan flags and chants crammed orchestra halls. Worldwide audiences and a rising Venezuelan diaspora overseas welcomed the orchestra evening after evening. Again in 2007, members of the youth orchestra had given their brightly coloured jackets, donning the Venezuelan flag, to viewers members after their London performances. Almost 20 years later, Mendonça says followers got here to return these jackets to the brand new musicians who at the moment are part of SBSO.
“It was loopy for us in London,” she laughs. “I feel it was a public that was ready for our sound.”
It was in that very same metropolis that SBSO recorded their now Grammy-nominated rendition of Ravel’s Boléro. Mendonça says the composition displays the orchestra’s historical past and legacy. “For me, the piece represents what El Sistema means,” she explains. “It is self-discipline, it is order, it is construction — but it surely’s a sense and a dedication [of] rising up as a rustic. For me, it’s totally particular.”
In an announcement shared with NPR, Dudamel agreed. “It was a pleasure to convey our Sistema soul to Boléro — some of the iconic works, not simply in classical music, however in all of music — infusing it with our distinctive DNA of how we conceive sound, and the way we strategy music-making,” he wrote.
SBSO’s North American dates proved to be trickier. The orchestra’s Los Angeles performances, scheduled to happen on the Hollywood Bowl over the summer time, had been canceled as a consequence of “journey issues.” (Venezuela is among the international locations on President Trump’s newest journey ban). The present continued elsewhere. In August, SBSO returned to London to carry out a 10-night run at Wembley Stadium with Coldplay.
“They [were] all carrying black fits and white trainers a la Dudamel. They [were] usually not studying the charts; they [were] wanting on the different musicians and on the conductor,” says Chirinos-Espin, who watched the performances. “I feel in 2025, they proved that they don’t seem to be solely nearly as good as they had been earlier than, however even perhaps higher.”
Chirinos-Espin largely credit Méndez’s management for that progress, and for his capability to maintain the orchestra enjoying and breaking new floor even within the face of Venezuela’s humanitarian disaster. For his half, the chief director says the Grammy nomination and Coldplay reveals sign what’s to come back for El Sistema’s subsequent 5 a long time.
“It is actually the start of a brand new period,” Méndez says. “What we obtain now is sort of a trampoline; we’re taking that impulse to advance and to go forward.”
