Thursday, July 31, 2025
HomeMusicIs 'Rust in Peace' Higher Than 'The Black Album'?

Is ‘Rust in Peace’ Higher Than ‘The Black Album’?

Evidently for fairly a number of music followers, the standard of an album is judged by what number of copies it has offered. And in sure circumstances, this principle definitely labored out ultimately: Michael Jackson’s Thriller, AC/DC’s Again in Black, Led Zeppelin’s IV, and so on.

However then you describe such extremely influential and common artists as Motörhead, the Ramones, and the Stooges promoting only a smidgeon of albums throughout their careers, when in comparison with the aforementioned goliaths?

In my 2025 ebook, The World’s State-Of-The-Artwork Velocity Steel Band: The Megadeth Story 1983-2002, there’s a part that focuses on the truth that whereas Metallica‘s The Black Album (launched in 1991) far outsold Megadeth’s Rust in Peace (launched in 1990), I state my case that Megadeth‘s album is definitely the higher of the 2. Right here is an excerpt by which two famend metalheads add their two cents…

And it was reassuring to listen to that whereas interviewing [former Lamb of God drummer] Chris Adler for this ebook, he additionally had an identical viewpoint as yours really. “When Rust in Peace got here out…and it wasn’t too lengthy after that The Black Album got here out, it was clear to me, like, ‘Wow, Megadeth wins. I’ve by no means heard something prefer it.’ I imply, simply the track ‘Holy Wars’ alone, I feel that is most likely the best heavy metallic track that is ever been written. However on the time, once more, I feel I used to be most likely 18 at that time, 17 possibly, and there have been songs on there that actually spoke to me. There have been these breakup songs of my past love and my first girlfriend and all that stuff – there was ‘Twister of Souls.'”

“And ‘Hangar 18’ – like, I am waking as much as the world and being like, ‘Oh shit. What’s Space 51?’ It hit on the proper time for me to be identical to, totally invested on this report and examine it in each approach that I might. And ultimately, attending to play among the songs was such a thrill of mine, however that album made an enormous distinction. I feel it was most likely essentially the most technically proficient metallic album up till its time that had ever been recorded. And I beloved each second of it.”

And because it seems, [comedian and That Metal Show co-host] Don Jamieson agrees with the daring views of each Prato and Adler. “Rust in Peace is certainly approach, approach higher than …And Justice for All. I am not a fan of that album in any respect. It is the straightforward manufacturing of the album greater than something – I simply do not like the way in which it sounds, so I by no means put the report on anymore. And I really feel like I do not thoughts lengthy songs in the event that they’re nice, however the lengthy songs on that album – to me – they’re all someplace round a minute too lengthy. So, Rust in Peace simply blows away …And Justice for All. These days, folks go, ‘Oh, Metallica put ‘Harvester of Sorrow’ within the set!’ I am like, ‘Oh God.’ That’d be a nightmare for me. That is the ‘beer track’ for me.”

However what about if Rust in Peace is healthier than The Black Album? “I winced a bit of once you mentioned The Black Album, as a result of it is one of many biggest-selling heavy information of all-time,” Jamieson admitted. “I assume folks contemplate Grasp of Puppets their masterpiece, however no doubt, The Black Album is their greatest album – their recognition exploded. However having a number of seconds to consider it, I additionally simply did a podcast the place we broke down all of the songs one after the other on The Black Album…and also you may be proper, man! It may be a tiny bit overrated. Whereas, there’s not too many boring moments on Rust in Peace. At worst, they’re even. However I may need to say – by a hair – Rust in Peace is the higher album.”


The Megadeth Story 1983-2002

The World’s State-Of-The-Artwork Velocity Steel Band: The Megadeth Story 1983-2002 is on the market as paperback, hardcover, and Kindle variations. Click on right here to order.

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments