Expertise the magic of Lemon Scrumptious! Also referred to as Self-Saucing Lemon Pudding or Lemon Pudding Cake, one batter separates into a lightweight soufflé-like sponge with silky lemon custard sauce beneath. Not only a wimpy quantity. This has lots of sauce!
Bonus: It’s a cocktail party dessert dream as a result of it reheats brilliantly. Particularly in ramekins!

Lemon Scrumptious Pudding
Lemon Scrumptious Pudding is a comfortable dessert that’s actually the proper approach to end a hearty meal throughout chilly winter days. The lemon custard sauce seems wealthy and creamy, but it surely’s really vibrant and tangy, and the sponge layer is extremely mild, nearly like a soufflé.
It’s a nostalgic Australian favorite that’s additionally effectively beloved within the UK and New Zealand, whereas the American model, often called Lemon Pudding Cake, is comparable however has a layer of thicker custard below the cake reasonably than a drizzle-able sauce.
Whereas Chocolate and Butterscotch Self Saucing Puddings have existed on right here for a few years, in truth, the lemon model by no means excited me previously as a result of I at all times discovered the sauce half …… underwhelming. Only a token skinny layer, most of which soaked into the cake, whereas I wished a superb quantity of sauce I may scoop up and spoon over each chew. Like this:

Little did I do know that my grievances had been extensively shared till readers requested it in droves after a call-out for winter recipes on Instagram! This sparked an obsession to create the Lemon Scrumptious I’d at all times wished. And there actually isn’t any different phrase than obsession to explain how I went about tackling this. It’s simply how I’m wired – I get fixated on perfecting a recipe for one thing I actually wish to eat, and I make it over and time and again till I get there!
And right here’s the maddening half about creating this recipe – you may’t inform if it labored simply by it. Each Lemon Scrumptious appeared like a hit popping out of the oven. It’s solely once I dug via the cake layer that I knew if the sauce labored or not!

However I did get there, and even JB was mighty impressed with the ultimate model. Or maybe astonished is the higher phrase, given how totally different it was to my first try. I’ve to chuckle remembering how restrained and well mannered he was about that one, which in some way managed to be dry, crumbly, means too candy AND eye-wateringly bitter .
It takes talent to make a pudding like that! 😂
And whereas I keep in mind, YES, you may make this in particular person ramekins too! (So many exclamation marks already, and I haven’t even began speaking in regards to the recipe 😂)



Components in Lemon Scrumptious
Right here’s what you’ll want to make Lemon Scrumptious. All pantry fundamentals – besides lemons, until you’re fortunate sufficient to have a tree within the yard you may pluck one from!
I even have a deep appreciation for any recipe the place dairy components can go in straight from the fridge – eggs, milk and butter. No have to plan forward and convey something to room temperature!

-
Lemons – You’ll want 2 massive lemons to get 1 tablespoon of zest and 1/2 cup of juice for this recipe. Enjoyable truth: it’s the zest that gives a lot of the lemon flavour, whereas the juice primarily provides tartness reasonably than lemon flavour. 🙂
-
Sugar – I exploit caster sugar / superfine sugar as my default for baking recipes, however common sugar (granulated sugar) will work tremendous too.
The recipe requires 1 cup (200g) of white sugar. I do know that appears like lots, but it surely’s wanted to stability the lemon juice – in any other case the pudding is much too bitter. I do know as a result of considered one of my early variations used half the sugar, and it was so tart it was inedible.
-
Milk – Use full fats milk in the event you can, because the lemon custard sauce comes out nicer. Only a higher mouthfeel, like utilizing full fats versus low-fat cream.
-
Flour – Simply plain flour (all-purpose flour), and never very a lot in any respect – simply 1/3 cup (50g) which is why the sponge layer comes out extra like a fragile soufflé reasonably than a cake.
It can’t be substituted with self-raising flour. The truth is, this pudding doesn’t use baking powder or baking soda in any respect – it will get its rise solely from whipped egg whites.
-
Eggs – Use massive eggs, that are eggs from cartons labelled “massive eggs”, ~50 – 55g/2oz every (in shell). Fridge chilly is ok, it doesn’t must be dropped at room temperature.
-
Unsalted butter – Fridge chilly, minimize up into cubes to assist it soften evenly.
-
Vanilla extract – That is non-compulsory, for a contact of additional flavour.
-
Salt – A pinch, to convey out the flavours on this dessert.

The Magic of Lemon Scrumptious: How It Works
The phrase “magic” actually is what involves thoughts when you consider how one batter could make such a stunning delicate sponge cake and a lot silky lemon custard sauce! However right here’s the way it really works – the skinny batter has whipped egg whites folded via it which is what makes the cake rise. Whenever you cease stirring, you’ll see it begin separating nearly instantly, with a foamy half (from the egg whites) rising to the highest whereas a darker colored lemon combination settles beneath.
It then bakes similar to that – the egg white layer turns into the sunshine sponge, whereas the lemon combination transforms into that superb silky custard sauce.


Tips on how to make Lemon Scrumptious
Most Lemon Scrumptious recipes begin by creaming softened butter with an electrical beater, then you need to wash it earlier than whipping egg whites to fold into the batter. I exploit melted butter as a substitute so the whole lot could be blended with only a hand-held whisk and the (clear!) electrical beater reserved for the egg whites. Plus, no want to recollect to melt the butter first!

-
Soften the butter in a heatproof bowl within the microwave till nearly melted, then whisk by hand to complete melting it. This fashion, the butter isn’t too scorching so we don’t want to attend for it to chill a bit.
-
Skinny batter – Whisk the sugar in first (it is going to be thick like moist sand) utilizing a handheld whisk. Then add the egg yolks, lemon juice, vanilla and salt and whisk till mixed. Add the flour and whisk till lump free, then whisk within the milk. It is going to be a really skinny, runny batter.

-
Beat egg whites to stiff peaks utilizing an electrical mixer or stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment. By stiff peaks, I imply upright pointy Santa hats, not floppy elf hats (that’s softly whipped).

-
Fold via – Fold a giant scoop of the fluffed egg whites into the batter first (this lightens the batter and makes the remaining simpler to fold via), then fold via the remainder of the egg whites. By “fold”, I imply use a rubber spatula to softly stir with massive scooping motions, reasonably than vigorous stirring, to keep away from knocking the air out of the egg whites.
-
One baking dish – Gently pour the combination right into a 5 to six cup ceramic baking dish (1.25 – 1.5 litres / quarts). I desire utilizing a smaller dish with taller sides reasonably than a flatter one as you get a thicker sponge layer, however it’ll work regardless of the form.
I don’t suggest utilizing a steel pan, it conducts warmth sooner and extra immediately so the custard sauce cooks extra and it’s thicker. Nonetheless good, however finally ends up extra like a thick dollop custard reasonably than a sauce.

-
Particular person ramekins – You too can use ramekins to make particular person parts. Six 200ml / 7 oz ramekins is the proper measurement, else you need to use no matter measurement baking dishes you wish to divide 5 cups of batter (12.5 litres / quarts). The pudding barely rises because it bakes so you may fill it to 1 cm / 0.2″ from the highest.
-
Water tub – Place the baking dish or ramekins into a big pan and fill midway up the perimeters with boiling water. Baking in a water tub makes the pudding prepare dinner evenly and gently so the cake half is fantastically mild and moist and the custard sauce beneath doesn’t dry out.

-
Bake – Bake for 35 minutes if making a big single one, or half-hour if making particular person ones, or till the highest is mild golden. It’ll nonetheless really feel jiggly in the event you poke it due to the sauce beneath.
-
Relaxation for five minutes to present the sponge an opportunity to stabilise (it is rather delicate scorching out of the oven). Give it a dusting of icing sugar (makes the whole lot prettier), then serve, taking massive scoops out of the dish, being positive to scoop up loads of sauce too! A dollop of whipped cream or creme fraiche is extremely really useful because it actually compliments the tangy lemon flavour.
Garnish choices – Just a little slice of lemon, raspberry and mint sprig are little garnishes you may add for a contact of color, and offers it a bit “ceremonial dinner” vibe. 🙂

Making Lemon Scrumptious forward
Talking of dinner events – I made an unintended discovery whereas reheating leftover Lemon Scrumptious for breakfast at some point (don’t decide me, there have been lots of leftovers throughout testing!). It reheats nearly completely! On a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 being fresh-from-the-oven perfection, I give it a 9.
And I don’t hand out 9’s calmly!!
Simply refrigerate till required, then reheat within the microwave. The sponge fluffs again up fantastically and the lemon custard turns into a heat pouring sauce once more. And you are able to do it for both a single massive pudding or particular person – although ramekins reheat higher as a result of they’re simpler to warmth evenly.
Actually, in case your visitors don’t catch you utilizing the microwave, I’d wager they’d by no means guess they weren’t freshly baked!! – Nagi x
Lemon Scrumptious FAQ
Sure, you may make this with orange or lime. Begin utilizing the identical juice and zest amount per the recipe. Then whenever you’ve blended the batter, earlier than folding within the fluffed egg whites, have a style and if you’d like extra flavour, add as much as an additional 2 tablespoons of juice and as a lot zest as you need.
It’ll hold within the fridge for 3 to 4 days after making it. The longer it’s saved, the extra the custard sauce will soak the cake half. However actually, it was nonetheless very pleasing on day 4!
When you’re planning to make forward then reheat to serve, attempt to make it nearer to serving time because it reheats higher in the event you make it on the day-of in comparison with the day earlier than.
Sadly not, the sauce will get watery and form of splits, and you may’t precisely stir it when it’s buried below cake! 🙂
Sadly I haven’t tried this with gluten-free flour however I really feel like this has a superb probability of working as a result of it’s leavened with egg whites reasonably than baking powder.
I checked out quite a lot of recipes earlier than developing with my very own. Flour, butter and milk ratios fluctuate extensively, with Australian and UK recipes utilizing much more flour than American ones (as little as 3 tablespoons vs 125g / 1/2 cup for Australian recipes), resulting in extra cake-like sponge layers, whereas the Individuals ones had been so mild, they had been extra like a soufflé (a bit too moist for my style, to be trustworthy).
American recipes additionally tended to make use of extra egg (often 4 in comparison with 3 eggs for Australian / British recipes), ensuing within the sauce layer ending up extra like a baked custard (ie very thick) reasonably than a sauce.
The excellent news is that each one the recipes I attempted – even early model of my very own – separated right into a cake and sauce / custard layer. It’s excellent news as a result of it confirmed that the self-saucing magic of the recipe is definitely fairly foolproof. The query of how good every of these parts had been was one other matter. 🙂
The place my recipe differs from typical recipes is that it makes use of 50% extra milk which is how I get a lot extra sauce. Whereas 1/2 cup further of milk may not sound like a lot, it thins the batter considerably and leads to greater than 1/2 cup further of lemon cream sauce.
No have to make a separate sauce: I additionally tried making a sauce individually and pouring that onto a thick cake batter, anticipating it to settle and thicken below the cake, very similar to Chocolate Self Saucing Pudding. It labored, however really, it’s an pointless further step as a result of that is basically what occurs whenever you combine up the batter – whenever you cease stirring, you’ll see it separates nearly instantly with the ethereal egg whites rising to the highest half whereas the thinner lemon combination settles on the bottom and that is what turns into the sauce.
Watch the way to make it
Hungry for extra? Subscribe to my publication and observe alongside on Fb, Pinterest and Instagram for the entire newest updates.

Lemon Scrumptious Pudding – further saucy!
Dessert
British, English, Western
Servings5
Faucet or hover to scale
Stop display from sleeping
Directions
ABBREVIATED RECIPE
-
Soften butter, whisk in sugar, vanilla and zest. Whisk in yolks and lemon juice. Whisk in flour, then milk. Beat whites to stiff peaks, fold into batter. Bake in 5- 6 cup dish in water tub at 180°C/350°F (160°C fan) for 35 min (ramekins 30 min).
FULL RECIPE
-
Preheat oven to 180°C/350°F (160°C fan-forced).
-
Baking vessels (Be aware 1) – You’ll need a 5 to six cup ceramic or glass baking dish (1.25 – 1.5 litres / quarts), or 6 x 200 ml / 7oz ramekins. No have to grease it.
-
Barely soften butter – Put the butter cubes in a heatproof bowl and microwave in 20 second increments till nearly melted. Then whisk by hand to complete melting utilizing the residual warmth – it’ll look milky reasonably than a yellow oil. (Be aware 2)
-
Make batter – Add the sugar, vanilla and lemon zest into the butter. Whisk to mix. Add lemon juice and egg yolks, whisk to mix. Add flour and whisk till lump free. Add milk and whisk. The batter shall be very skinny!
-
Beat whites – In a separate bowl, beat the egg whites till stiff utilizing a handheld beater or stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment. You need upright reasonably than floppy Santa hats!
-
Fold via a giant scoop of the fluffed egg whites into the batter utilizing a rubber spatula. Then add the remaining egg whites in and fold via, do not stir vigorously (Be aware 3 for what I imply by this). Little lumps of egg whites is ok.
-
Fill – Gently pour the batter into the baking dish and put it in a bigger roasting pan. Ramekins: Use a ladle, and ensure to scoop from the underside so each ramekin will get even quantities of foamy batter (which sits on the floor), this turns into the cake. Fill to 1 cm / 0.2″ from the rim. Switch to a pan for water tub.
-
Bake in water tub – Fill pan with boiling water till it comes midway up the facet of the baking dish. Bake 35 minutes for a single dish or half-hour for ramekins, till the floor is golden (it’ll really feel jiggly in the event you prod it due to the sauce beneath).
-
Relaxation for five minutes, then dusting with icing sugar. Scoop out to serve, making certain everybody will get their share of the lemon custard sauce! High with a dollop of whipped cream or creme fraiche, and enhance with little lemon slices, raspberry and mint sprig if desired.
Recipe Notes:
Ramekins – 6 x 200 – 250ml / 7 – 8 oz ramekins are the best measurement. Or you need to use bigger or smaller, simply calculate what number of you’ll want based mostly on the amount of batter.
Steel pans will work too (20 – 23cm/8 – 9″ spherical, 5cm/2″ tall) however ceramic dishes makes a softer cake and looser sauce, and likewise current nicer too.
2. Barely melting butter – This prevents the melted butter from getting too scorching so it doesn’t soften components added into it. However in the event you absolutely soften the butter and it’s fairly scorching, that’s tremendous – simply set it apart for a couple of minutes to chill down earlier than continuing with the recipe.
3. Folding via egg whites – Including a little bit of whipped egg whites into the batter first lightens the batter and makes the remaining simpler to fold via. Use a rubber spatula to softly stir with massive scooping motions, reasonably than vigorous stirring, to keep away from knocking the air out of the egg whites.
Leftovers will hold for 3 – 4 days within the fridge. Reheat gently within the microwave.
Make-ahead – Reheats amazingly effectively, so terrific for dinner events! Make the pudding per recipe and absolutely cool uncovered. Refrigerate, then reheat within the microwave till the centre is heat. The lemon custard sauce will loosen and the sponge will spring again!
Time information – one ramekin takes me 40 seconds on excessive. Do 30 second increments, decreasing time of bursts because it will get hotter.
Ramekins reheat higher (smaller = extra even reheating), and the nearer you may make it to serving time, the extra excellent it is going to be when reheated.
Diet per serving, assuming 5 servings.
Diet Info:
Energy: 350cal (18%)Carbohydrates: 52g (17%)Protein: 7g (14%)Fats: 14g (22%)Saturated Fats: 8g (50%)Polyunsaturated Fats: 1gMonounsaturated Fats: 4gTrans Fats: 0.5gLdl cholesterol: 130mg (43%)Sodium: 73mg (3%)Potassium: 174mg (5%)Fiber: 0.3g (1%)Sugar: 44g (49%)Vitamin A: 516IU (10%)Vitamin C: 10mg (12%)Calcium: 106mg (11%)Iron: 1mg (6%)
Extra cosy puddings and desserts
Lifetime of Jaffle
And similar to that, my candy little pet enters his wild little one period ……
Present standing:
-
4 months and 6 days previous
-
20 kg (40 lb) – placing on 1 kg each week
-
Meals consumption – 800g / 1.6lb every day plus undetermined amount of treats 😇
-
Vitality ranges – limitless
-
Private area consciousness – none
-
Recall success charge (with treats) – varies considerably relying on close by distractions (canines, birds, sticks)
-
Present life philosophy – if it strikes, chase it. If it doesn’t transfer, see if it’ll.
-
Favorite family merchandise – skirting boards and something mum is carrying.
Level down with a digital camera at any time and there’s a excessive likelihood of capturing this precise shot 😂:

Ahhh, however for all of the naughtiness, this not-so-little-anymore fur ball has completely stolen my coronary heart.

And that’s in all probability the final photograph you’ll see of me holding him. 😂
