Main spoilers for Wake Up Lifeless Man: A Knives Out Thriller” comply with. There are additionally some mild spoilers for “Weapons.”
I am not making waves once I say Josh Brolin is a really, excellent actor. That is been true for a very long time. A “nepo child” from a time earlier than we even used the time period “nepo child” — his dad is actor James Brolin, and his stepmother is Barbara Streisand — the youthful Brolin rose to prominence due to “The Goonies” in 1985 earlier than fading from prominence for some time after which making an extremely sturdy return in 2007 with “No Nation for Outdated Males.” Within the years since then, Brolin has appeared in every thing from the Marvel Cinematic Universe — most notably in “Avengers: Infinity Conflict” and “Avengers: Endgame” because the über-villain Thanos — to Denis Villeneuve’s “Dune” diversifications (wherein he performs Atreides weapons grasp Gurney Halleck). Now, in 2025, Brolin is getting some main time within the highlight thanks largely to his look in not one, not two, however three blockbuster films this 12 months: Zach Cregger’s “Weapons,” Edgar Wright’s “The Working Man,” and Rian Johnson’s “Wake Up Lifeless Man: A Knives Out Thriller.”
As of this writing, I, fairly sadly, have not seen “The Working Man” but, so I am going to regrettably should omit that from my dialogue. Nonetheless, even with out that film, Brolin is having a banner 12 months by any requirements. From his loudly grieving dad in “Weapons” to his unbelievably impolite and offensive Catholic monsignor in “Wake Up Lifeless Man,” Brolin is exhibiting off his vary, and we’re all higher for it, as a result of other than “The Working Man,” he will get to mess around with two completely completely different characters in two very completely different films.
Certainly one of this 12 months’s largest horror hits, Weapons, contains a radically completely different efficiency from Josh Brolin
It is vital for me to notice that due to delays brought on by the 2023 WGA and SAG-AFTRA strike, Zach Cregger’s sophomore function movie “Weapons” ended up recasting virtually all people save for Austin Abrams (who performs the down-and-out James, maybe the movie’s funniest character). That features the function of Archer Graff, who was initially going to be performed by Pedro Pascal earlier than the star needed to drop out attributable to his commitments to Marvel’s “Improbable 4” movie. After Pascal parted methods with the venture, Brolin signed on. As a lot as I actually love Pascal, I am so glad that Brolin ended up taking part in Archer.
We solely see Archer, at first — within the chapter devoted to elementary faculty trainer Justine Gandy (Julia Garner), whose complete class of scholars disappeared mysteriously one evening save for one boy — from behind and in profile as he will get indignant at a parent-teacher assembly, however earlier than lengthy, we get to his chapter. There, we see a portrait of a profoundly damaged man grieving his misplaced son (one of many children who bumped into the evening for causes no one is aware of simply but), who sleeps in his son’s deserted mattress amidst a rising divide together with his spouse. Determined to seek out his child, Archer’s fury and bluster is at all times rooted in actuality, as a result of you recognize all he needs is to seek out his son and produce him house. (Additionally, after a nightmare in his son’s mattress, Brolin, as Archer, delivers one of many best possible line readings of the 12 months.)
The superb factor about Brolin’s Archer and his Jefferson Wicks is how distinct they’re; even when Archer is being a jerk, you continue to root for him. Jefferson? Not a lot.
Josh Brolin’s flip as Monsignor Jefferson Wicks in Wake Up Lifeless Man makes all the film work completely
Archer Graff in “Weapons” is a bit brusque, however it’s for a decidedly noble trigger; Monsignor Jefferson Wicks is a complete jerk to everybody for mainly no cause in any respect. In “Wake Up Lifeless Man,” Jefferson Wicks — who runs a church known as Our Girl of Perpetual Fortitude that “welcomes” new reverend Jud Duplenticy (Josh O’Connor) in the beginning of the film — is a small-minded and genuinely merciless man who preaches hatred and bigotry to his flock, maintaining them complacent but afraid of his energy as he gleefully drives away newcomers. (Some of the memorably and expertly deployed montages within the film options Jefferson’s raging sermons in full silence whereas folks affected by his phrases, together with queer {couples} and single moms, flee Our Girl of Perpetual Fortitude in apparent misery.) He is hypocritical (fathered a secret illegitimate son and bullied a person into taking the blame), imply (psychologically torments Jud consistently), and even violent (he throws a Bible at Jud in a single scene).
On some stage, these two characters sound kind of comparable, however they’re decidedly not. Archer’s humanity steadily comes via whilst he is frothing on the mouth to seek out the one that’s liable for his son’s disappearance, however Jefferson has mainly no semblance of humanity anymore as a person who’s been raised on spite, resentment, and pure vitriol (I imply, the man completely refers to his late mom because the “harlot whore” as a result of she had him out of wedlock!). Brolin is a grasp of his craft, and I am comfortable to see that the world has lastly realized this. “Weapons” is streaming on HBO Max now, and “Wake Up Lifeless Man: A Knives Out Thriller” is now on Netflix.
